Skip to content

Thrift Stores

Hearts for the Homeless® Thrift Store
2217 Sheridan Drive
Buffalo, NY 14223

(Near Anderson's)

Hours of Operation

Monday to Saturday

9:00 AM - 8:00 PM

Donation Receiving Hours

Monday to Saturday

9:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Hearts for the Homeless® Thrift Store
890 Tonawanda Street
Buffalo, NY 14207

(Near thruway entrance/exit - accessible from Niagara Street.)

Hours of Operation

Monday to Saturday

10:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Donation Receiving Hours

Monday to Saturday

9:30 AM - 4:00 PM

Exciting News: Our Second Location is Now Open!

We're excited to announce the opening of our second location at 2217 Sheridan Dr. Tonawanda, NY 14223. Our new store will offer the same great selection of donated quality clothing, accessories, shoes, and household items at affordable prices, along with the warm and welcoming environment that our customers have come to love. We can't wait to expand our impact in the Tonawanda community and continue supporting our outreach programs. When you shop at the Hearts Thrift Stores, you help support our mission.

D3639622-EDD0-4775-94FA-1D05734900FA_1_201_a
3EBB4F91-1973-4D40-9880-4B19EBA3B95C_1_201_a
FCCD0194-7EA6-429C-B8F6-03F85970AA9C_1_201_a
image (1)

Shop with Confidence

The original Hearts Thrift Store offers a wide variety of quality clothing, accessories, shoes, and household items at prices that won't break the bank. Conveniently located on Tonawanda Street in Buffalo, our original store provides a shopping solution for residents of a poverty-stricken area who may not have access to malls and suburban shopping centers in Western New York. When you step inside our stores, you'll be greeted by soothing Christian music and our friendly Hearts team members, creating a relaxing environment for your shopping experience. 

Our location on Tonawanda Street, which has been in business since 1997, has become a fabric of the community. It is a convenient one-stop-shop for everyone, offering not only quality men's clothing and accessories, but also personal care items, toiletries, and jewelry for any occasion at affordable prices. Beyond the main room, you'll discover our men's clothing room, where you can find a wide range of charitable men's clothing items, donated shoes, children's books, and housewares. You'll discover incredible bargains on quality clothing for the entire family, as well as toys, home decor, games, and free books.

All profits from Hearts Thrift Stores go towards supporting our various outreach programs, many of which are located on the Hearts Campus. Our operations are designed to meet the needs of individuals and families in our local WNY community. By shopping with us, you'll not only find amazing deals, but you'll also be supporting our mission to improve the quality of life for those in need.

Warm Welcome

IMG_5985-2

Christian music in the background welcomes shoppers into the Main Room, where customers often comment how they feel a sense of peace and their stressed relieved as they enjoy their surroundings while they shop.

Community Convenience

IMG_5963

Shoppers in the Main Room will also find jewelry and various personal care items & toiletries, as well as the check-out, where our staff is waiting to assist them in finding items, sizes, and give them encouragement along the way.

Main Room

IMG_5995

With two customer entrances and good quality at affordable prices, our Main Room has a bright atmosphere and is our largest shopping area with women’s clothing, shoes & accessories; kids clothing, toys, games, and more.

Men's Room

IMG_5979

Enter the men's area and explore gently used men's clothing, accessories, shoes, sporting equipment, and more. You can expect to find a great selection of movies starting as low as $1 in the Men’s Room, as well as video games.

Support Our Mission by Donating Gently Used Items

You can also help support our mission by donating your gently used clothing, accessories, linens, and small household items in good condition. You can drop off donated items during our operating hours at any Hearts Thrift Stores location, or at one of our 400 donation bins available 24/7, 365 days a year. To find a donation bin and a list of acceptable donations, visit our bin finder page. We also accept donations online, through your employer, or by mail.

Hearts Loyalty Program

Join Heart’s new Loyalty Program to enjoy exclusive discounts, benefits and rewards just by being a loyalty program member. Plus, you’ll even receive a birthday coupon by email. Sign up in store today and get $5 off your next purchase of $25 or more. Redeem your $5 discount within 30 days of signing up. Sign up to start earning points and start saving today! https://heartsforthehomeless.org/loyalty-program/

Birthday Savings

Color Tag Sale

Elevate your shopping experience at the Hearts Thrift Stores, where savings are always in style. A simple look at the tag color can unlock amazing deals! Our Heart Thrift Store locations have a unique offer for you: 50% off on all merchandise marked with a specific colored tag. So, every time you shop at the Hearts Thrift Stores, you're not only finding one-of-a-kind items, but also making incredible savings.

Color Tag Sale

Hearts for the Homeless® desires to improve the quality of life for the people in Buffalo and to spread the Good News of Jesus Christ.

What folks are saying about us:

Diamond in the rough. Always find name brand clothes, household and eclectic items. Legos too! Great prices. Better than Savers because it actually goes toward helping people. Put Hearts Thrift Store on your to-do list!

Gretchen Wiser Avatar Gretchen Wiser
February 16, 2022

Love going here. Always come out with a shopping cart full and don't pay much. The staff is very friendly. They have a basket full of free stuff. They also have a pantry in the same lot and the staff is just as friendly. Today they gave out Turkeys for Thanksgiving and I made them cupcakes to accompany their package.

FLORENCIA MUNOZ Avatar FLORENCIA MUNOZ
November 21, 2022

The services that these people are doing are just amazing. Not only do they sell donated clothes for super cheap, they also will give out clothes (primarily for men) for free if you ask them to. On top of that, when asked if they take food donations they said that they have a kitchen that they make and source food out of to a soup kitchen. Just a wonderful establishment Buffalo should be proud of housing.

Sha Med Avatar Sha Med
July 2, 2018

A true hidden gem of a thrift store in the heart of the Riverside neighborhood of the City. You can find many good buys here. Everything from clothes to housewares to even antiques, they have a very wide selection at incredibly low prices. They also accept gently used and clean donations here or at one of the numerous collection boxes that they have placed around the City. And the best part? All profits go right back into the community from their great work in helping homeless folks in our area. And even better news is that they are going to be expanding their facilities very soon! I would give them 10 stars if I could!

Geoffrey Snyder Avatar Geoffrey Snyder
August 11, 2019