Skip to content

Hearts Thrift Store in Tonawanda

Hearts for the Homeless® Thrift Store
2217 Sheridan Drive
Tonawanda, NY 14223

(Near Anderson's)

Hours of Operation

Monday to Saturday

9:00 AM - 8:00 PM

Donation Receiving Hours

Monday to Saturday

9:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Hearts Thrift Store on Sheridan Drive: Now Open!

We are thrilled to welcome you to our newly opened second location at 2217 Sheridan Drive. Opened on December 9, 2023, this expansion allows us to offer a larger selection of high-quality, brand name clothing, accessories, shoes, and household items at the right prices.

What Sets Us Apart:

  • Top Brands, Affordable Prices: Discover a wide array of top brand names known for their quality, ensuring you always find the best value for your money.
  • Inclusive Shopping Experience: Our store is equipped with large ADA-compliant fitting rooms and handicap-accessible bathrooms to provide a comfortable and inclusive shopping experience.
  • Family-Friendly Shopping: Enjoy our double seat fire truck themed shopping cart, making your family shopping trips fun and engaging.

When you shop at Hearts Thrift Stores, you directly support the Hearts for the Homeless® outreach programs designed to improve the lives of individuals and families in the Western New York community.

image (1)

Support Our Mission:

At Hearts for the Homeless®, we are driven by a profound spiritual motivation to share the Word of God and provide essential services to the chronic homeless, poor, and those in need in our community. Our mission extends beyond clothing and feeding; it's about nourishing the soul, offering hope, and building a future for those we serve.

Make a Difference with Every Purchase

Each time you shop at the Hearts Thrift Stores, you're not just purchasing quality items at great prices—you're also contributing to the provision of nourishing food and clothing to those who need them most. Your purchases help us fund these critical services, allowing us to reach more people every day.

Donate and Make an Impact:

You can further support our mission by donating your gently used clothing and household items. These donations are either directly provided to those in need or sold at our stores to raise funds for our outreach efforts. This cycle of giving enables us to offer companionship, pertinent information about area services, and hope to our community members facing hardships.

Drop off your items Monday through Saturday 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM or use any of our 400 outdoor donation bins available 24/7. 

Hearts Loyalty Program

Join Heart’s new Loyalty Program to enjoy exclusive discounts, benefits and rewards just by being a loyalty program member. Plus, you’ll even receive a birthday coupon. Sign up in store today and get $5 off your next purchase of $25 or more. Redeem your $5 discount within 30 days of signing up. Sign up to start earning points and start saving today!

Birthday Savings

Color Tag Sale

Elevate your shopping experience at the Hearts Thrift Stores, where savings are always in style. A simple look at the tag color can unlock amazing deals! Our Heart Thrift Store locations have a unique offer for you: 50% off on all merchandise marked with a specific colored tag. So, every time you shop at the Hearts Thrift Stores, you're not only finding one-of-a-kind items, but also making incredible savings.

Color Tag Sale

Hearts for the Homeless® desires to improve the quality of life for the people in Buffalo and to spread the Good News of Jesus Christ.