Skip to content

Making Thrift Shopping An Experience

The Hearts Thrift Store, our newest location at 2217 Sheridan Drive, welcomed its first customers on December 9, 2023. In just a short time, it’s quickly become a popular spot for Western New Yorkers searching for quality secondhand goods.

The store boasts a vast assortment of donated items, including clothes, accessories, shoes,  and household items at affordable prices; along with a warm and welcoming environment that our customers have come to love. You will find amazing deals on new and gently used name brand and designer clothing at a fraction of their original price. Better brands for great values is what you’ll find at the new Hearts Thrift Store. 

The store is designed with all customers in mind. We have ADA-compliant fitting rooms, a handicap accessible restroom and convenient shopping carts. There’s even a double-seater fire truck-themed shopping cart for a fun family shopping experience. 


The store’s location on the bustling Sheridan Drive amid restaurants, fitness centers, and schools, makes it a lively section of the Tonawanda community. We invite everyone to enjoy an exciting shopping experience at the new Hearts Thrift Store. 

By shopping at our new store, you’ll be contributing to the Tonawanda community as well as supporting Hearts’ outreach initiatives. Every purchase made at the Hearts Thrift Store helps uphold our mission of serving those in need across Western New York.

Store Location: 2217 Sheridan Drive. Tonawanda, NY 14223

Hours of Operation: Monday through Saturday 9:00 AM – 8:00 PM

For more information, visit the Hearts Thrift Store on Sheridan Drive webpage.